All of Lynns belongings, along with the Jeep, were returned to Harold. However, Harold kept insisting on his innocence and in 2017 appealed for a retrial which was subsequently shot down. The Denver Channel, 7News, brings you the latest trusted news and information for Denver, Colorado, Mile High and. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. He tossed the flat in the back, as Harold had said hed done in one version of his story. Every morning, she wakes up asking herself, "Did it really happen? Toni was either a blessing to the people that surrounded her or a lesson to those that she mentored.Toni used her extraordinary abilities to become an accomplished medical physician in the specialty of ophthalmology. Detective Weaver further discovered that the department was woefully undertrained: the man in charge of the investigation had been a detective for all of five months, had never been the lead on any homicide, and had never undergone any formal training before becoming a detective. "Believe it or not I forgive him (Henthorn) for doing it. To one cop, Harold said the tire they pulled over to change was completely flat. Douglas County had changed tremendously in the intervening years. Then came Harold. Henthorn has sociopathic tendencies, without doubt, but what makes this so challenging is that a murderer is typically not a sociopath. Montoya wanted to cover his wife with something warm. Tom Sizemore, Heat and Saving Private Ryan Actor, Dead at 61 In 2019, he filed a petition for a writ of certiorari, urging the U.S. Supreme Court to investigate the matter, which was again denied. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. The strange saga of Henthorn and his two ill-fated wives began back in the spring of 1995. When Harold Henthorns second wife, Dr. Toni Henthorn, appeared to lose her life after a tragic fall, authorities became suspicious of the two times widower. Friends and family were delighted for the pair, who seemed to be the perfect match. He pushed her, said Tonis father, Bob. Toni had fallen off a cliff? It was only a few days into the new year, 2013, and only a few weeks after the Douglas County Sheriffs Department received a curious letter. After years of trying, the two managed to have a daughter, Haley. The Bertolets found it odd that long after shed ceased to be a baby, Harold kept a video monitor running in his daughters room. The family had enough money. Afterwards she would discover what it was that had hurt her so badly: a large piece of lumber that Harold said fell off the porch. A true parent places a childs needs above their own selfish wants. The Douglas County Sheriffs employees registered Harolds conflicting statements and made note of the strange fact that the spare tire he said he was going to use was barely more inflated than the one he was removing. It appeared instead to be a terrible accident. Grief is place where one never wishes to remain; yet it will be our unending passage due to the wrongful acts of the Defendant. He refused to allow Toni to help put Haley to bed at night, insisting that the hour or so before Haley fell asleep was his daddy-daughter time. The case now before Weaver was different, though. It seemed to be a tragic accident. The Danger of Manipulative Love-Bombing in a Relationship, 7 Ticking Time Bombs That Destroy Loving Relationships, An Addiction Myth That Needs to Be Revisited, 5 Spiritual Practices That Increase Well-Being. Reading through the file 18 years later, Detective Weaver realized something, which would later come out in court testimony from his superiors: that in almost every one of those conversations Harold made a statement that conflicted with something else hed already said. No physical evidence remained. In September of 2015, three years after the incident, a jury found Harold Henthorn guilty of first-degree murder in the case of Toni Henthorns death. The Bertolets had accepted those quirks early on because thats what a good family does they worked hard at liking the person that made their daughter happy. This is "Dateline NBC: Henthorn Case" by Vicky Collins on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them. Toni was a successful eye surgeon yet she wanted nothing more than to be in a loving marriage and have a family. She Used the Bathroom And Became a Target of the Culture War, Here's How LaRussell and Intuit are Helping Independent Artists Understand How to Achieve Their Financial Ambitions, Alex Murdaugh Sentenced to Life in Prison for Murder of Wife and Son, Alex Murdaugh Found Guilty of Murdering Wife and Son, Tennessee Enacts Nations First Law Restricting Drag Shows, The National Stay Up Late to Perform 'Tropic Morning News' on Fallon, David Lindley, Multi-Instrumentalist Who Shaped the Sound of Soft Rock, Dead at 78, Suki Waterhouse Won't Take Romance for Granted on New Single 'To Love', Travis Barker Says His Finger Ligament Surgery Was a 'Success' After Postponing Blink-182 Tour. Family, friends and co-workers were convinced Harold Henthorn was responsible for his wife's death. But, as the lead investigator would later testify to in court, theyd never checked the print against the shoes to see if they were a match. He was 50 when his wife Toni passed away. Now he needed an answer to a question that was gnawing at him. The couple met online in late 1999 and got married only nine months later, both in a rush to. Detective Weaver discovered that there were multiple witnesses to the accidents aftermath who were never contacted. After being found guilty of first-degree murder, Harold received a life term in federal prison in 2015. In the Defendants selfish quest to hoard a child as a possession, he interfered with and severed a sacred relationshipthat of a mothers love for her child and the childs need for the love her mother. When Dave Weaver first sat down with the file he wasnt impressed. Gary Clexton, a court-appointed special administrator representing Toni Henthorn's estate, declined to discuss the new court case involving Rob Henthorn and the half million dollars. The Defendant demeaned the investigative authorities for uncovering his murder and sinister intentions. Months later, when they got the news that she was dead, and that she had died while alone with Harold, her father Bob said what most in the family were already thinking. When Detective Weaver called her nearly 20 years later and asked if she had any idea why he, an officer from Douglas County, might be calling out of the blue, Montoyas answer came quick and definitive. Editors picks His bosses told him to work the case the same way he worked every other case, which meant to go where the truth led, no matter where it led. One night, something happened at that cabin that left Toni recovering in a hospital bed. Harold was convicted of first-degree murder, and in 2015 was sentenced to life in federal prison. Unlucky in love, but a success just about everywhere else. CBS4 Investigator Brian Maass has been with the station more than 30 years uncovering waste, fraud and corruption. The Sheriffs Office grew with it, from a few dozen to some 500 employees. document.write(" Is Blue Gatorade Ok For Colonoscopy, Articles H